Main News

What is Criminally Negligent Homicide?


Criminally negligent homicide refers to instances where a person’s carelessness, recklessness, or negligence results in the loss of another’s life. While lacking the intentional elements of murder or manslaughter, it can still lead to severe criminal charges with long-lasting repercussions. These charges can strongly impact your personal freedom, reputation, employment prospects, and overall quality of life.

Defending against a criminally negligent homicide charge is a complex process that necessitates expert guidance. Seeking the assistance of a seasoned New York criminal defense attorney is crucial in such cases. With their experience and legal acumen, they can adeptly handle the charges, explore potential defenses, and effectively represent you in court. Don’t hesitate to contact a skilled criminal defense attorney today to secure the best possible outcome for your case. 

In today’s competitive legal industry, maintaining a strong online presence and effective digital marketing strategies are essential. This is where BSPE Legal Marketing stands out, providing invaluable support to criminal defense law firms. Leveraging our expertise in SEO and digital marketing, we empower law firms to enhance their online visibility, attracting potential clients seeking representation in mistrial cases or other criminal defense matters. Our tailored approach to search engine optimization ensures that law firms achieve higher rankings in relevant search results, bolstering their online authority and credibility. To take your criminal defense law firm to new heights, contact us today. Discover how our digital marketing services can help you engage your target audience, establish thought leadership, and forge a strong online reputation.

Are you a criminal defense law firm looking to expand your online presence and attract more clients?

This website is owned by BSPE Legal Marketing – and we are #1 for a reason. For a free SEO review and detailed analysis schedule a call today!

What is Homicide?

Homicide is a legal term for any killing of a human being by another human being. Homicide itself is not always a crime—for instance, a justifiable killing of a suspect by the police or a necessary killing in self-defense. However, unlawful homicides are divided into two major categories: murder and manslaughter. The difference between the two usually revolves around the killer’s mental state and intent.

Homicide laws vary widely from country to country. In most Western legal systems, a homicide is justifiable if it prevents a serious crime, such as rape, armed robbery, manslaughter, or murder. In these cases, the act is not considered criminal, as it is viewed as a necessary measure for self-defense or the defense of another.

Defenses to Negligent HomicideDescriptionApplicability
Self-DefenseJustified force used to protect self or others.Applicable when there’s a reasonable belief of imminent harm, and the response is proportionate to the threat.
Lack of IntentUnintentional act; no negligence involved.Applicable when defendant’s actions were accidental and lacked negligence.
Involuntary IntoxicationImpaired judgment due to involuntary substance influence.Potentially applicable when involuntary intoxication led to impaired actions and resulted in death.
Mistake of FactHonest and reasonable mistake leading to negligence.Relevant when defendant’s actions were based on a reasonable belief, but an unintentional mistake occurred.

Types of Homicide

Homicide is a legal term for any killing of a human being by another human being. In many jurisdictions, it’s divided into several different categories, often based on the circumstances of the act and the intent of the perpetrator. Here are the most common types of homicides:

  • Murder: Murder is a serious crime that involves the unlawful killing of another human being with malice aforethought.
    • First-Degree Murder: This is the most serious form of homicide, generally defined as an unlawful killing that is both willful and premeditated, meaning that it was committed after planning or “lying in wait” for the victim.
    • Second-Degree Murder: Unlike first-degree murder, second-degree murder does not require premeditation. Instead, it typically involves an intentional killing that is not premeditated or planned, or a death caused by dangerous conduct with a lack of concern for human life.
  • Manslaughter: Manslaughter is a lesser form of homicide, defined as the unlawful killing of a human being without malice aforethought. It’s further divided into two types:
    • Voluntary Manslaughter (also called “heat of passion” murder): This includes killings that occur in the “heat of passion” in response to a provocation that would cause a reasonable person to lose self-control.
    • Involuntary Manslaughter (also called “negligent homicide”): This refers to unintentional killings resulting from recklessness or criminal negligence, or from an unlawful act that is a misdemeanor or low-level felony (such as a DUI).
  • Vehicular Homicide: This is a crime that involves the death of a person other than the driver as a result of either criminally negligent or murderous operation of a motor vehicle.
  • Justifiable Homicide: This term refers to situations where the killer is not considered at fault, such as self-defense or the defense of others where danger of death or serious harm was imminent. The specific circumstances that constitute justifiable homicide depend on the particular legal jurisdiction.

These categories can vary significantly in their specifics from one jurisdiction to another, and different countries may use different terms or classifications. Each type carries different legal implications and potential sentences. In New York, crimes falling under the category of homicide are under NY Penal Law § 125.

Are You a Criminal Attorney Growing Your Practice?

Our “short and sweet” emails offer 1 daily practical tip you can implement to increase your online visibility today. Each tip takes 5 to 10 minutes to implement.

P.S. We will never sell your information.

The Role of Negligence in Criminally Negligent Homicide

Negligence is generally defined as the failure to exercise the level of care that a reasonable person would have exercised in the same situation and as such is a defining factor in criminally negligent homicide (New York Penal Law § 125.10). Under the law, criminal negligence in this context refers to actions or omissions that create a risk of harm to others and result in death.

The distinguishing factor of negligent homicide from other forms of homicide is the absence of intentional harm or malice aforethought. Instead, the offense is characterized by carelessness, inattentiveness, or disregard for the safety and well-being of others. This might involve actions that are inherently dangerous, or benign actions carried out in a dangerous manner.

Duty of Care

“Duty of Care” is a legal concept that refers to the responsibility one person has to avoid causing harm to another. In criminally negligent homicide cases, the accused is usually someone who had a duty of care towards the victim. This could be a professional duty, such as a doctor’s duty to their patient, or a general duty, like every driver’s duty to drive responsibly and not cause harm to others.

The duty of care is a basic principle that everyone in society should take reasonable care to avoid actions or omissions, which can reasonably be foreseen to injure others. In a criminally negligent homicide case, it must be established that the accused had a duty of care toward the victim and that they failed to uphold this duty.

Breach of Duty

A breach of duty occurs when one person or party has a duty of care toward another person or party but fails to live up to that standard. To successfully prosecute a case of criminally negligent homicide, it must be proven that the defendant breached the duty of care they owed to the victim.

This breach could be an act or a failure to act. For instance, a doctor might fail to diagnose a condition properly, leading to the patient’s death, or a driver might cause a fatal accident by driving recklessly. In both cases, the person in question failed to act as a reasonable person would have under the same circumstances, thereby breaching their duty of care.


The final element that must be established in a criminally negligent homicide is causation. It must be shown that the defendant’s breach of duty directly caused the death of the victim. This is often where criminally negligent homicide cases are won or lost, as proving causation can be complex.

Causation involves establishing that the harm would not have occurred but for the defendant’s actions. This is often referred to as “but-for” causation. If the harm would have occurred regardless of the defendant’s actions, then the defendant cannot be held responsible for the harm.

Furthermore, the harm must be a foreseeable result of the defendant’s actions. That is, a reasonable person would have anticipated that the defendant’s actions could lead to the kind of harm suffered by the victim. For example, a reasonable person would foresee that driving recklessly could lead to a fatal accident.

Criminally negligent homicide is a complex area of law that revolves around the concepts of negligence, duty of care, breach of duty, and causation. Proving these elements can be a complicated task, requiring a deep understanding of legal principles and a careful analysis of the facts at hand. Despite its challenges, understanding the elements of criminally negligent homicide is crucial for legal professionals, as it forms a significant part of many criminal cases.

Proving Criminally Negligent Homicide

Proving criminally negligent homicide involves establishing the elements of negligence, duty of care, breach of duty, and causation. The prosecution must show that the defendant owed a duty of care to the victim, breached that duty through negligent behavior, and that this breach directly resulted in the victim’s death.

The Burden of Proof

In criminal cases, the burden of proof always lies with the prosecution. This means that it is the prosecution’s responsibility to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty of the charges. This high standard is intended to protect individuals from being unjustly convicted.

Beyond a reasonable doubt means that the evidence presented leaves no other logical explanation than the defendant’s guilt. If there is any reasonable doubt in the minds of the jury, then they must acquit the defendant. This does not mean that the prosecution must eliminate all doubt, only doubts that are reasonable.

Evidence Required

Evidence in a criminally negligent homicide case can come in many forms. This includes but is not limited to: eyewitness testimonies, physical evidence, medical reports, police reports, and sometimes expert opinions.

Eyewitness testimonies can provide a firsthand account of the incident, while physical evidence such as skid marks or vehicle damage in a car accident can help reconstruct the event. Medical reports can help establish the cause of death, and police reports can provide an unbiased, third-party account of the event.

In complex cases, particularly those involving technical or specialized knowledge, such as medical malpractice cases, the prosecution may need to rely on expert opinions. This leads us to the next point.

Expert Witnesses

Expert witnesses play a critical role in many criminally negligent homicide cases. These are individuals with specialized knowledge, skills, experience, training, or education that can assist the court in understanding the issues at hand.

In a criminally negligent homicide case, an expert witness might be called upon to explain medical terminology, reconstruct a car accident, or provide an opinion on whether the defendant’s actions were reasonable under the circumstances. The expert’s testimony can help establish whether the defendant breached their duty of care and whether that breach directly caused the victim’s death.

Proving a criminally negligent homicide involves a complex interplay of factors, including establishing the elements of negligence, meeting the burden of proof, presenting compelling evidence, and sometimes relying on the testimony of expert witnesses. It’s a rigorous process that ensures that justice is served, the guilty are held accountable, and the innocent are protected.

Penalties for Criminally Negligent Homicide

Criminally negligent homicide, while less severe than intentional homicide, still bears serious legal consequences. The penalties for this offense are designed to balance the need for justice and deterrence with the recognition that the offender did not intend to cause death. This section will explore sentencing guidelines, factors affecting the penalty, and potential penalties for criminally negligent homicide.

Sentencing Guidelines

Criminally negligent homicide is a class E felony in New York. As such, a conviction can carry a sentence of up to 4 years in jail in addition to the payment of hefty fines. Judges often consider factors such as the offender’s criminal history and the nature and circumstances of the offense. The judge may also consider whether the offender shows any remorse or willingness to reform.

Factors Affecting the Penalty

Several factors can influence the severity of the penalty for criminally negligent homicide. These can include:

  • Degree of Negligence: The level of negligence displayed by the offender can impact the severity of the sentence. Recklessness and lack of remorse may result in a more severe penalty.
  • Criminal History: A defendant with a history of similar offenses or a significant criminal record may face a more severe penalty than a first-time offender.
  • Remorse and Rehabilitation: If the offender shows genuine remorse for their actions or takes steps toward rehabilitation, the court may consider this in mitigation during sentencing.

The penalties for criminally negligent homicide are serious, reflecting the gravity of the offense and the need for justice. Working with a skilled attorney can help in negotiating the terms of the penalties and securing a more favorable outcome.

Are you a criminal defense law firm looking to expand your online presence and attract more clients?

This website is owned by BSPE Legal Marketing – and we are #1 for a reason. For a free SEO review and detailed analysis schedule a call today!

Defenses to Criminally Negligent Homicide

Each charge of involuntary manslaughter  presents a unique set of circumstances. As such, defendants are allowed to present defenses to counter the charges laid against them. Depending on the specifics of the case, different defense strategies may be more applicable and effective. This section will explore several defenses that may be used in a criminally negligent homicide case, including self-defense, lack of intent, involuntary intoxication, and mistake of fact.

Lack of Intent

Lack of intent is a key defense strategy in such cases, given that criminally negligent homicide is an unintentional act. The defense must prove that the defendant’s actions were not negligent and that any harm caused was truly accidental.

However, this defense does not absolve a defendant of all responsibility. The prosecution can still argue that, while the defendant did not intend harm, they failed to exercise the degree of care a reasonable person would under the same circumstances, and this negligence led to the death.

Mistake of Fact

A mistake of fact defense arises when the defendant made an honest and reasonable mistake that led to the negligent act. This defense can be particularly relevant in cases where the defendant had a legitimate reason to believe that their actions were safe or necessary.

For instance, consider a case where a hunter accidentally shoots a person, mistaking them for an animal. If the hunter can demonstrate that they took all reasonable precautions and genuinely believed they were shooting at an animal, they may be able to use a mistake of fact defense.

Mounting a defense to a charge of criminally negligent homicide requires careful examination of the facts and a deep understanding of the law. Regardless of the defense strategy chosen, the goal remains the same: to challenge the prosecution’s case and raise reasonable doubt in the minds of the jury.

Are You a Criminal Attorney Growing Your Practice?

Our “short and sweet” emails offer 1 daily practical tip you can implement to increase your online visibility today. Each tip takes 5 to 10 minutes to implement.

P.S. We will never sell your information.

Working with a Competent Criminal Defense Attorney

Criminally negligent homicide pertains to causing unintentional death through reckless or careless behavior, blurring the line between an unfortunate accident and a potential criminal act.

A skilled attorney specializing in these cases plays a crucial role in safeguarding the defendant’s rights and ensuring a fair trial. Through meticulous examination of the presented evidence, the attorney can build persuasive arguments that advocate for the defendant’s best interests. Their expertise and experience can work towards seeking a favorable resolution, which may potentially reduce the severe consequences that come with this type of charge.

Time is of the essence when facing a criminally negligent homicide charge; securing professional legal representation promptly can be the key to mounting a strong defense. An experienced New York criminal defense attorney will not only have in-depth knowledge of the legal system but also understand the nuances specific to the type of case. Their guidance can provide a fair chance at justice, protecting your rights, and preserving your future and freedom.

If you or someone you know is in this challenging situation, it is essential to act swiftly and seek the guidance of a reliable criminal defense attorney. Having the right legal support by your side can make all the difference in the outcome of the case. Contact an experienced criminal defense attorney today to ensure that your rights are upheld and that you receive a fair and just legal process.

Learn More

If you’re wondering what is negligent homicide, you’re not alone. The case of negligent homicide is one that has a number of nuances. If the defendant caused or allowed a person to die due to their own reckless behavior, you may be accused of criminal negligence homicide. Here’s a look at the legal definition of this crime. If you are guilty of negligent homicide, you can face a criminal charge, including the death penalty.

A driver who fails to stop at a stop sign is a prime example of a negligent homicide case. This homicide case involving a train is an example of how a negligent homicide charge could come about. Whether a driver intentionally accelerated a train or merely neglected to slow down the vehicle as it neared a stop sign, the underlying legal concept is the same: the defendant failed to recognize a substantial and unjustifiable risk. It must also be of a nature that constitutes a gross deviation from a reasonable person’s standard of care.

The penalties for a negligent homicide conviction depend on several factors. A prior criminal history is a strong factor, as is the amount of time a person must spend in prison. The felony label comes with social stigma. Having this label makes it extremely difficult to find and keep a job. A negligent homicide lawyer will present various reasonable alternatives to the prosecution’s case. The penalties for negligent homicide are severe, and even the most minor infractions will result in a lengthy prison sentence.

A defendant accused of negligent homicide should focus on a criminal defense that attacks the causation and awareness of unjustifiable risk. While this may be difficult to overcome, there are some defenses to this charge. These include alibi defenses and challenging the credibility of prosecution evidence. It’s important to understand the legal defenses of negligent homicide and be prepared for a difficult legal battle. If you have a defense, you’ll be able to beat the charge.

If you’re charged with negligent homicide, the best thing to do is consult with an attorney immediately. In most cases, defendants can request a lesser charge instead of the higher degree of homicide. This charge carries a lower punishment range, so you’re able to argue that you were responsible for the accident. It may give the defendant credibility with the jury, resulting in a short prison sentence.

Negligent homicide is a misdemeanor, but if the victim was driving under the influence of alcohol, the charge could become a felony. A felony conviction would entail a one to 15-year prison sentence. The punishment for negligent homicide can vary between states, but in most states, the minimum punishment is one year in prison. If the person responsible for the death died as a result of someone else’s negligence, the defendant is liable for the death and must pay restitution to the family.

If you’re charged with negligent homicide in Arizona, the crime is a Class 4 felony. This type of crime carries a more severe punishment than a misdemeanor, and a felony conviction means a longer prison sentence, a loss of liberty and some rights. In addition, you’ll lose your firearm license, and your criminal record will go on record. If you’ve been charged with negligent homicide, make sure to speak with a lawyer as soon as possible.

Share with your friends on
Main News
The first step to preparing for a misdemeanor crime defense case is to hire a...
Main News
If you are facing criminal charges, the first thing to do is to find a...
Main News
If you’ve recently been arrested and received a desk appearance ticket, you’re probably wondering: What...
Main News
‘Harboring a fugitive’ refers to the act of knowingly providing assistance or shelter to an...
Main News
Homicide involves the killing of one person by another and encompasses various circumstances and motives....
Featured ArticlesMain News
In New Jersey, both murder and manslaughter are serious criminal offenses involving the unlawful killing...
Are You a Criminal Attorney Growing Your Practice?

Our “short and sweet” emails offer 1 daily practical tip you can implement to increase your online visibility today. Each tip takes 5 to 10 minutes to implement.

P.S. We will never sell your information.